Josiah has played soccer since he was a child. He received numerous awards as a four year starter at Conestoga Valley HS. He then played for Messiah College, where he won a national championship. After a couple years off, he returned to finish his collegiate career at Lancaster Bible College where he was a three year captain, two time All-American, and conference MVP. He currently plays on a local semi-professional team. He spent a year as the assistant varsity coach at Conestoga Valley, as well as being a soccer instructor for multiple soccer camps and clinics.